Previous Section Back to Table Of Contents
APPENDIX I
SURVEY OF U.S. UNILATERAL ECONOMIC SANCTIONS
January 11, 1997
Prepared with Assistance of Don Zarin and Meha Shah
Dechert, Price & Rhoads, Washington, D.C.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTIONThis Survey sets forth in summary fashion the current U.S. laws and regulations that authorize or mandate U.S. unilateral economic sanctions in order to achieve certain foreign policy objectives. This includes the deliberate imposition or threatened imposition of unilateral economic sanctions to change the behavior of a foreign nation with respect to its own conduct, or the conduct of its nationals. The foreign policy objectives can be far reaching and include the transition to democracy, opposing terrorism or support of terrorist activities, sanctioning drug producing and drug-transit countries, supporting human rights, opposing the acquisition of weapons of mass destruction, and protecting the environment. The sanctions that may be imposed include blocking of assets and a prohibition on all dealings with a foreign country and its nationals, restrictions on exports to or imports from a particular country or foreign person, the withholding of financial assistance or trade benefits from a foreign country, a ban on participation in U.S. government procurement, and opposition by U.S. representatives in international financial institutions to loans or financial assistance to a particular country.
This Survey does not incorporate standard export controls undertaken pursuant to multilateral agreements, such as the Nuclear Suppliers Group, the Australia Group, or the Missile Technologies Control Regime. However, where U.S. economic sanctions exceed the agreed upon level of multilateral sanctions, such sanctions would be identified and included herein. The Survey also does not include unilateral export controls imposed on the sale of defense articles or specified dual-use items which facilitate the proliferation of conventional or non-conventional weapons, violations of human rights, and terrorism1. While these controls are unilaterally imposed for foreign policy purposes, they are intended more to avoid diversion of these items to a targeted activity rather than to affect the policy or behavior of certain States.
On the other hand, we have included in this Survey the imposition or threatened imposition of unilateral economic sanctions to encourage foreign governments and their nationals to modify their environmental practices, including fishery conservation practices and the preservation of sea turtles. Such sanctions are intended to achieve foreign policy goals, and not commercial or trade objectives.
Finally, we have excluded from this Survey sanctions that are imposed or threatened to be imposed to attain trade or commercial objectives. For example, the use or threatened use of trade sanctions under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, as amended, to encourage foreign governments to provide market access for U.S. goods, is not included.
I. SANCTIONS TARGETED AT INDIVIDUAL COUNTRIES
A. International Emergency Economic Powers Act, as amended ("IEEPA"),
Pub. L. 95-223, Title II, 91 Stat. 1626 (October 28, 1977), as amended, 50 U.S.C.A. §§ 1701-1706 (West 1991 & Supp. 1996)Sections 202 and 203 of this Act authorize the President to take broad measures to regulate financial transactions and trade in order to "deal with any unusual and extraordinary threat which has its source in whole or substantial part outside the United States" to the U.S. national security, foreign policy, or economy of the United States. The President must first declare a national emergency.
Trade and financial transaction restrictions invoked under this Act are currently being applied as follows:
- Iranian Sanctions2
The Iranian Transactions Regulations, administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control ("OFAC"), prohibit U.S. persons from engaging in certain activity related to the development of petroleum resources located in Iran. Exec. Order No. 12957 (3/15/95). The regulations also prohibit most activity, including brokering and financing, related to trade in Iranian goods and services. Exports of goods, technology, and services from the United States to Iran are prohibited. Reexports of certain U.S. origin goods and technology are also prohibited. Investments by U.S. persons in Iran also are prohibited. U.S. persons may not approve or facilitate the performance of any prohibited transaction by a foreign subsidiary of a U.S. firm. Exec. Order No. 12959 (5/6/95)3.
The OFAC Iranian Assets Control Regulations block all property of the Government of Iran and of the Central Bank of Iran within the jurisdiction of the United States. Exec. Order No. 12170 (11/14/79). These regulations have been modified, but the blocking of some assets continues today, and most transactions with respect to such property are prohibited.
- Libyan Sanctions Regulations 4
Economic sanctions imposed on Libya include a prohibition on trade, transportation, travel to Libya, and extensions of credit to the Libyan Government. Exec. Order No. 12543 (1/7/86). The property and interests of the Libyan Government, and persons or organizations acting on its behalf, were also blocked. Most transactions with respect to blocked property are prohibited. Exec. Order No. 12544 (1/8/86). The regulations prohibit essentially all exports of goods, technology and services from the United States to Libya, either directly or through third countries. Exports of U.S. goods through third countries are permitted, except for application in the Libyan petroleum sector, if the goods will be substantially transformed in the third country, or will form part of the inventory of a distributor whose sales are not predominantly to Libya. Imports of Libyan origin goods into the United States also are prohibited, with minor exceptions.
B. Trading With The Enemy Act, as amended ("TWEA"),
Act of October 16, 1917, c. 106, 40 Stat. 415, as amended,
50 U.S.C.A. App. §§ 1-44 (West 1990 & Supp. 1996)Section 5 of this Act prohibits trade with "the enemy" during time of war. However, the scope of the authority granted to the President under this Act had been used to control transactions during peacetime. Congress amended the Act in 1977 to limit the President's authority to wartime, but authorized the continuation of trade restrictions invoked prior to 1977.
Trade restrictions invoked under this Act are currently being applied as follows:
C. Iraq Sanctions Act of 199015,
Pub. L. 101-513, Title V, §§586A-J, 104 Stat. 2047 (November 5, 1990), note to 50 U.S.C.A. § 1701 (West 1991)This Act was enacted as a response to the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. Congress determined that the Government of Iraq is engaged in the gross violation of internationally recognized human rights, and explicitly imposed all sanctions applied to it under the authority of existing legislation stemming from such status (including denial of assistance under the Foreign Assistance Act and instructions to U.S. executive directors of multilateral banks to vote against financial assistance).
This Act also applies the following sanctions to Iraq:
denial of sales by the U.S. Government and licenses for export of defense items and services controlled under the Arms Export Control Act;
denial of licenses for exports of certain goods controlled under the Export Administration Act;
denial of licenses for exports of certain nuclear material, technology and components controlled under the Atomic Energy Act; and
denial of assistance from the Export-Import Bank.
These sanctions may be waived by the President upon certification that Iraq has made certain improvements in domestic policy and that there has been a change of leadership in Iraq.
This Act also restricts exports of supercomputers to countries whose governments are found to be assisting Iraq's weapons capabilities.
D. Iran-Iraq Arms Non-Proliferation Act of 1992, as amended16,
Pub. L. 102-484, Div. A., Title XVI, 106 Stat. 2571 (October 23, 1992), note to 50 U.S.C.A. §1701 (West Supp. 1996)Section 1603 of this Act applies the same export and licensing prohibitions to Iran as are applied against Iraq pursuant to the Iraq Sanctions Act of 1990 (discussed above at section I.C.).
Section 1604 also prohibits "any" person from transferring goods or technology that contribute to the ability of Iran or Iraq to acquire advanced conventional weapons17, or chemical, biological, or nuclear weapons . Mandatory sanctions include denial of export licenses and a ban on entry into U.S. Government procurement contracts.
Sanctions also are required against foreign governments that transfer goods or technology which contribute to the ability of Iran or Iraq to acquire advanced conventional weapons. Mandatory sanctions include suspension of U.S. Government assistance, the requirement that U.S. representatives at international financial institutions vote against financial assistance, and the suspension of certain military transfers and sales. The President is also authorized to impose additional trade restrictions as permitted under IEEPA.
The President is authorized to waive the prohibitions contained in this Act in the national interest of the United States.
E. Cuban Democracy Act of 199218,
Pub. L. 102-484, Div. A, Title XVII, 106 Stat. 2575 (October 23, 1992), 22 U.S.C.A. §§ 6001-6010 (West Supp. 1996)In enacting this legislation, the stated policy of Congress was, among other things, to encourage a transition to democracy in Cuba by strengthening trade restrictions and by providing support for Cuba in the event it should begin to make that transition.
Section 1704(b) of this Act authorizes the President to apply sanctions against foreign countries providing "assistance" to Cuba. The prohibited "assistance" includes grants, concessional sales, guaranties, and insurance provided on terms more favorable than that generally available in the applicable market; and subsidies for exports to Cuba or favorable tariff treatment for imports of Cuban goods. Donations of food or exports of medicines or medical supplies are exempted. The sanctions to be applied include ineligibility for (i) assistance under the Foreign Assistance Act or the Arms Export Control Act; (ii) sales by the U.S. Government under the Arms Export Control Act, or (iii) U.S. Government debt reduction programs.
Section 1706 further strengthens the existing embargo against Cuba by prohibiting the issuance of licenses under the OFAC regulations to foreign subsidiaries of U.S. firms to conduct trade with Cuba, where the policy of the country in which the subsidiary was located favored such trade. See 31 C.F.R. § 515.559 (1995).
Section 1705 exempts food and most exports of medicine and medical supplies from trade restrictions. This section also permits telecommunication services between the U.S. and Cuba, and authorizes facilities providing those services. However, this provision has been amended to prohibit investment by U.S. persons in the Cuban domestic telecommunications network. See Cuban Liberty and Democratic Solidarity Act, Pub. L. 104-114, § 102(g), 110 Stat. 794 (3/12/96). Subsection 1706(b) also prohibits vessels carrying Cuban goods or persons, or which have engaged in trade at Cuban ports, from conducting certain activity in U.S. ports.
F. Cuban Liberty and Democratic Solidarity ("Libertad") Act of 199620,
Pub. L. 104-114, 110 Stat. 785 (March 12, 1996), 22 U.S.C.A. §§ 6031 et seq. (West 1996)This Act further restricts trade with Cuba by sanctioning "trafficking" by foreign persons in property that was confiscated from U.S. citizens. "Trafficking" includes selling, purchasing, leasing, obtaining control of or using confiscated property, engaging in commercial activity using or benefiting from confiscated property, or causing or participating in trafficking by another person.
Title III of the Act provides for a private right of action against traffickers by the U.S. claimants to the confiscated property in U.S. Federal District Courts. The President may suspend this provision for six month periods if it would be in the national interest and would expedite the transition to democracy in Cuba21. Under Title IV, foreign persons (and their spouses and children) determined to have engaged in trafficking may be denied visas for entry into the United States.
Section 102 codifies the existing OFAC regulations that impose an embargo on trade with Cuba (discussed at I.A.). See 31 C.F.R. Part 515 (1996). These sanctions are to remain in effect until a democratic transition is under way in Cuba.
Under Section 103, U.S. persons are prohibited from providing financing for transactions involving confiscated property.
Section 104 of the Act directs the U.S. executive directors of international financial institutions to oppose Cuban membership in those institutions. If any such institution approves financial assistance to Cuba over the opposition of the U.S., the Secretary of the Treasury is required to withhold certain payments by the U.S. to those institutions.
Section 106 also denies assistance under the Foreign Assistance Act to the independent states of the former Soviet Union if the President certifies that any member has assisted, or engaged in nonmarket based trade, with the Cuban government. Assistance will also be withheld from these countries in an amount equal to any assistance provided for the intelligence facilities at Lourdes, Cuba.
Section 111 of the Act prohibits U.S. foreign assistance to countries in an amount equal to the sum of assistance and credits provided by that country for the completion of the Juragua nuclear facility.
G. Iran and Libya Sanctions Act of 1996,
Pub. L. 104-172, 110 Stat. 1541 (August 5, 1996)In order to deny Iran and Libya the ability to support acts of terrorism and to acquire weapons of mass destruction, the provisions of this A97.ct mandate the imposition of sanctions on U.S. and foreign persons that engage in certain transactions with Iran and Libya22. Sanctioned Activities
- "Investment"23 of $40 million (or any combination of investments of at least $10 million each which in the aggregate equals or exceeds $40 million in any 12-month period) in the development of petroleum resources of Iran or Libya. (For Iran, the threshold reduces to $20 million after one year.)
- Providing to Libya any items prohibited under U.N. Resolutions No. 748 (aircraft, aircraft components and related services and technology, defense related goods, services and technical assistance), and No. 883 (certain oil refining equipment and equipment for the transport of oil).
The President is required to impose at least two of the following sanctions for a minimum of two years, in response to the above-referenced activity:
Denial of Export-Import Bank credits, guarantees or insurance;
The President may waive the imposition of sanctions if he determines it is in the national interest of the United States.Denial of licenses under the Arms Export Control Act, the Export
Administration Act, or the Atomic Energy Act;
Prohibition on loans from U.S. financial institutions;
If the sanctioned person is a financial institution:
(a) Prohibition from serving as a primary dealer of U.S. Government bonds;
(b) Prohibition from serving as a repository of U.S.Government funds;
Prohibition on entering into U.S. Government procurement contracts; or
Prohibition on imports pursuant to IEEPA.
H. 1997 Omnibus Appropriations Act,
Pub. L. 104-208, 110 Stat. 3009 (September 30, 1996)Section 570 of this Act prohibits most U.S. bilateral assistance and requires executive directors of international financial institutions to vote against funding with respect to Burma, until the President certifies that Burma has made certain progress in the area of human rights.
The President is also authorized, upon certification to Congress that Burma has taken specified acts, to prohibit certain investments in Burma by U.S. persons. This sanction may be invoked if the Government of Burma physically harms, arrests or exiles Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, or if it commits large-scale repression of, or violence against, the Democratic opposition.
Under Section 533, none of the funds appropriated by this Act to carry out the Foreign Assistance Act may be used to provide assistance to any country that is not in compliance with the U.N. Security Council sanctions against Iraq or Serbia and Montenegro. This prohibition does not apply to humanitarian aid or aid otherwise in the national interest of the United States.
The President is also authorized to prohibit the import of goods from foreign countries that have not enacted trade restrictions regarding Serbia, Montenegro and Iraq.
Section 540 of this Act also continues existing prohibitions on U.S. Government assistance to Serbia and Montenegro and instructions to U.S. executive directors at international financial institutions to vote against assistance to those governments. The Act also codifies existing blocking regulations under OFAC (see discussion under IEEPA above at I.A.). The President is authorized to permit assistance for reform projects or humanitarian aid, and may lift the sanctions upon certification that certain progress has been achieved towards self-rule and the improvement of human rights in the area of Kosova. The President is also authorized to waive the sanctions contained in this Act for humanitarian reasons, or to achieve a negotiated settlement of the conflict in Bosnia-Herzegovina24.
Section 553 prohibits the use of funds appropriated under this Act for assistance to the Palestine Liberation Organization ("PLO"), unless the prohibition under Section 307 of the Foreign Assistance Act (discussed at section IV) is suspended.
- The application of section 307 of the Foreign Assistance to the PLO has been waived until February 12, 1997 by the President. 61 Fed. Re. 43137 (8/12/96). This was authorized by the Middle East Peace Facilitation Act of 199525.
Section 507 prohibits the use of funds under this Act for direct assistance to Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, Sudan or Syria26.
Section 523 prohibits the use of funds under this Act for indirect assistance to Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, Syria, or the People's Republic of China. This prohibition may be waived by the President upon certification that this would be in the national interest.
Section 567 restricts funding under this Act for military assistance to Guatemala unless the President certifies that the Guatemalan military is cooperating in the investigation and resolution of human rights abuses in which the military allegedly participated.
Section 569 restricts funding for assistance to Haiti until the President reports that the Government of Haiti is conducting investigations, and participating with U.S. investigation efforts, of political killings. The President may waive this prohibition if it would be in the national interest.
Section 579 requires U.S. representatives in international financial institutions to vote against loans, other than for basic human needs, to any country which the Secretary of the Treasury determines to have, as a cultural custom, a history in the practice of female genital mutilation, and which government has not taken steps to implement educational programs to prevent such practice.
Section 508 prohibits funds available under this Act, including Overseas Private Investment Corporation ("OPIC") funds, from being used to assist any country whose duly elected Head of Government is deposed by military coup or decree, until a democratically elected government takes office.
This Act also prohibits the use of funds under the Foreign Assistance Act (discussed at section I.V.) for assistance to any New Independent States of the former Soviet Union that take action violating the territorial integrity or national sovereignty of any other New Independent State. Such funds also may not be used to assist Russia unless the Russian Government is making progress in implementing comprehensive economic reforms.
- The President waived the application of this provision with respect to violations of territorial integrity and national sovereignty. 62 Fed. Reg. 1381 (12/26/96).
I. Foreign Relations Authorization Act for 1990-91, as amended,
Pub. L. 101-246, Title IX, §§ 901-902, 104 Stat. 83 (February 16, 1990), as amended, note to 22 U.S.C.A. § 2151 (West Supp. 1996)This Act prohibits with respect to China
Overseas Private Investment Corporation financial support;
U.S. Government assistance under the Foreign Assistance Act;
the issuance of licenses for export of certain defense articles to certain end-users under the AECA;
the issuance of licenses for export of crime control and detection equipment under the EAR;
the export of certain satellites;
the issuance of licenses for export of certain nuclear material, technology or equipment; and
assistance under the Atomic Energy Act.
The prohibitions will be lifted when the President: (1) certifies that China has provided certain assurances that it is not assisting any non-nuclear weapon state in acquiring certain nuclear materials or devices, and reports that certain political reform progress has been made; (2) certifies that China has not used a nuclear explosive device or violated international nuclear safeguards (see Congressional Joint Resolution at II.E.4.); and (3) makes a report regarding China's progress in human rights and political reform.
Under Section 901, this Act also states that the President "should" urge the Export-Import Bank to postpone approval of financing related to China, and that the U.S. executive directors of international financial institutions "should" oppose the extension of assistance to China. The Act also states that the President "should" review certain trade agreements with respect to satellite launches and the use of atomic energy if systematic repression in China deepens.
J. Foreign Operations, Export Financing, and Related Programs Appropriations Act, 1996,
Pub. L. 104-107, Title V, 110 Stat. 720 (February 12, 1996), note to 50 U.S.C.A. § 1701 (West 1996)Section 540(a)-(c) of this Act continues prohibitions on U.S. Government assistance to Serbia and Montenegro and instructs U.S. executive directors at international financial institutions to vote against assistance to those governments. The Act also codifies existing blocking regulations from OFAC (see discussion under IEEPA above at I.A.) that implemented various Executive Orders. The President is authorized to permit assistance for reform projects or humanitarian aid27.
The President is authorized to lift the sanctions upon certification that certain progress with respect to the area of Kosova has been achieved. This includes progress towards:
a separate identity for Kosova;
the creation of an international protectorate for Kosova;
the right of the people of Kosova to govern themselves; and
substantial improvement in the human rights situation in Kosova.
The President is also authorized to waive the sanctions contained in this Act for humanitarian reasons, or to achieve a negotiated settlement of the conflict in Bosnia-Herzegovina28.
Under section 534, no funds under this Act may be used to provide assistance under the Arms Export Control Act or the Foreign Assistance Act to countries that do not comply with the United Nations sanctions against Iraq or Serbia and Montenegro, but the President may waive this prohibition for humanitarian assistance. The President is also authorized to prohibit imports of products from countries that have not undertaken trade restrictions with respect to Iraq or Serbia and Montenegro.
Under section 563, assistance is prohibited to a country if that country, or an entity within that country, provides assistance in the completion of the Juragua nuclear facility in Cuba. The prohibition does not apply to specified humanitarian assistance.
Section 507 prohibits the use of funds under this Act for direct assistance to Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, Serbia, Sudan or Syria29.
Section 523 prohibits the use of funds under this Act for indirect assistance to Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Libya, North Korea, Syria, or the People's Republic of China. This prohibition may be waived by the President upon certification that this would be in the national interest.
Section 567 prohibits the use of funds under this Act for narcotics control assistance to Burma.
Section 578 restricts funding for military assistance to Guatemala unless the President certifies that the Guatemalan military is cooperating in the investigation and resolution of human rights abuses in which the military allegedly participated.
Section 583 restricts funding for assistance to Haiti until the President reports that the Government of Haiti is conducting investigations, and participating with U.S. investigation efforts, of political killings. The President may waive this prohibition if it would be in the national interest.
Section 529 prohibits the sale of Stinger surface-to-air missiles under the Arms Export Control Act or the Foreign Assistance Act to any country bordering the Persian Gulf.
This Act also prohibits the use of funds under the Foreign Assistance Act (discussed at section I.V.) for assistance to any New Independent States of the former Soviet Union that take action violating the territorial integrity or national sovereignty of any other New Independent State. Such funds also may not be used to assist Russia unless the Russian government is making progress in implementing comprehensive economic reforms.
Section 508 prohibits funds available under this Act, including Overseas Private Investment Corporation ("OPIC") funds, from being used to assist any country whose duly elected Head of Government is deposed by military coup or decree, until a democratically elected government takes office.
- OPIC suspended activities in Gambia in 1994, and in Burundi in 1996 under this provision30.
Next Section Back to Appendix I
Table Of ContentsBack to Main
Table Of Contents
Home |
About Us |
Resources |
Press Releases |
Federal Activity & Legislation
Return to Top
State & Local Activity |
NFTC Lawsuit |
Contact Us |
Site Index